WE BUY AND SELL VINTAGE COMIC BOOKS, GRAPHIC NOVELS, VINTAGE TOYS, CARDS & MORE
.png)
PHYSICAL STORE COMING SOON TO BAY RIDGE, BROOKLYN! STAY TUNED FOR GRAND OPENING INFO!
.png)
WIDE SELECTION OF COMICS & TOYS
From superheroes and sci-fi to horror, indie gems, and vintage toys, our shelves are packed with treasures for every fan and every age.
WE BUY COMICS & TOYS
Ready to sell? We pay fair prices for single issues, key books, entire collections, and classic toys.
HONEST, EXPERT ADVICE
Our team knows the hobby inside and out. Whether you’re valuing a collection, tracking down a rare toy, or searching for your next favorite series, we’re here to help.
There’s nothing like the thrill of flipping through real comics and finding that perfect collectible in a real shop. Stop by, browse, and rediscover the magic—right here in your neighborhood.
Buy. Sell. Collect. Connect.
Only at NY Comics.
LIVE-STREAM COMIC SHOWS ON WHATNOT
We host live-stream comic sales several times a week, that are not only fun and entertaining, but also a perfect way to grow your comic book collection with great deals and rare finds.
Follow us on Whatnot @NY_Comics and join the community to see what treasure might pop up next!
Whether you're a new collector or a longtime comic fan, our Whatnot streams are packed with energy, expert insights, and unbeatable comic book drops — all from the heart of New York City.
.png)
ABOUT US
Big News: We’re Opening in
Bay Ridge, Brooklyn!
We’re thrilled to announce that NY Comic Shop is opening a physical storefront right in the heart of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. Stay tuned for more updates and our official opening date! At NY Comic Shop, we specialize in buying and selling comic books, graphic novels, vintage toys, and collectibles — from the Golden Age of the 1930s to today’s newest releases.
Since day one, we've proudly offered top dollar for entire collections — no cherry-picking, no lowballing. Based in Brooklyn, we also travel throughout the tri-state area to purchase full collections.
Whether you're looking to sell comics, toys, or collectibles — or just exploring your options — we make the process easy, transparent, and respectful. We’ll walk you through our evaluation process and explain how we determine value based on condition, rarity, and overall quality. And of course, we’re always happy to answer your questions along the way.